International Journal of Engineering Research in Mechanical and Civil Engineering (IJERMCE)

Monthly Journal for Mechanical and Civil Engineering

Volume2,April 2017,

Topic : Study on the Progressive Collapse Behaviour of Steel and RCC Moment Resisting Frames

Authors:Rithika Nanaiya || Imtiyaz A Parvez,Kiran Kamath

Abstract:One of the key requirements for any major construction is the structural safety of the building along with the ability to resist partial or total collapse. One or more structural elements fail due to abnormal loading leading to the collapse of the entire structure progressively. This phenomenon is referred to as Progressive Collapse. Seismic loading may also cause progressive collapse of the structure due to repeated lateral loading on a critical load bearing element in a building in seismically prone regions. The capacity of a building has been analysed to resist collapse of a 15 storey 3D Steel and RCC moment resisting frames. They have been modelled and designed for seismic zone 5 as per Indian Standards using ETABS. Three scenarios of column removal namely middle, corner and interior has been studied by the linear method of analysis to arrive at the most critical location of column loss. The Demand Capacity Ratio (DCR) has been assessed in the critical regions as per the provisions of GSA guidelines. Further, the variation in the maximum vertical displacement values for both the steel and RCC structures has been compared. The study concludes that the loss of column in the corner location proved more susceptible to collapse by comparing the DCR values. It has also been observed that a steel building has the ability to resist collapse following the loss of a column when compared to an RCC building..

Keywords: DCR, linear static analysis, moment resisting frames, Progressive collapse, seismic

Download Paper

DOI: 01.1617/vol4/iss4/pid52379

Related Articles

RFID Technology in Construction Project Management – A Review

Authors: Rounak Bhushan Singh || Sumeet Sagar,Animesh Sinha,Muneesh Methwani

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss03/pid49278

Volume2 ,March 2017.

RFID Technology in Construction Project Management – A Review

Authors: S.Pachaiappan || Dr.S.Palanivel

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss03/pid49278

Volume2 ,March 2017.

Experimental Study of Steel Fibers Reinforced Concrete over Conventional Concrete

Authors: Varsha Harne || Suyog U. Dhote

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss03/pid83154

Volume2 ,March 2017.

Experimental Investigations of Rubber Seed Oil Methyl Ester-Diesel and Butanol-Diesel Blend by Using Diesel Engine

Authors: Vishal V. Patil || Utkarsh Shidhganesh,Somesh Shinde,Mahesh Gurav,Swapnil Ulagadde

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss2/pid72430

Volume2 ,February 2017.

Study of Land Acquisition Issues causing delay of NHAI Projects

Authors: Rounak Bhushan Singh || SumeetSagar, Animesh Sinha

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss4/pid73465

Volume2 ,April 2017.

Study on Strength and Durability Properties of Bacteria Concrete

Authors: Phani Kumar. V || V. Sainath,Ashok Varma

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss3/pid03875

Volume2 ,March 2017.

Influence of Masonary Infill on The Behaviour of RC Frames

Authors: R.Vigneshwaran || Dr.K.Pandurangan

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss3/pid01729

Volume2 ,March 2017.

Design of Smart Rolling Shutters for Low Cost Operations

Authors: Kushali Sindhia || Madhumitha Prakash,Dr. S. V. Satish

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss3/pid49615

Volume2 ,March 2017.

An Experimental Investigation on Behavior of High Volume Alkali Activated Flyash Concrete

Authors: K.Sasidhar || S. Aruna Jyothy,Dr. B. Damodhara Reddy

Doi : 01.1617/vol4/iss3/pid64813

Volume2 ,March 2017.


Editor Image

Meinhard Taher Schobeiri
Texas A & M University, USA.

View more


ISSN(Online): 2456-1290

Google Scholar Profile

Thomson Reuters ID : q-6288-2016.
ORCiD Research ID : 0000-0001-9540-6799

All Issues


Journal Code : IJERMCE
Electronic ISSN : 2456-1290
Impact Factor : 3.8
Frequency : monthly
Contact :

IFERP Other Journals